Matthew 22:15-22
St Peter’s Kinver, 18th October 2026
I have a question for you. I have to warn you it’s quite a tricky question, one that I have wrestled with an awful lot over the years.
The question is this: Do we live in a Christian country?
Now I’m not going to make you answer this question, not least because I suspect that here among us there are a whole range of understandings of what the question means, let alone what the answer should be?
But I am going to share some of my thoughts on it, and I will emphasise that they are only my thoughts – you might disagree and you are perfectly entitled to do so (except for Rev’d Emma who obviously has to agree with me on everything otherwise I won’t sign off her Curacy paperwork!)
So my basic answer to that question – do we live in a Christian country – is, no we don’t, because I don’t think a country can be ‘Christian’.
A person can be a Christian, of course! I’m a Christian, I’m sure most if not all of you are Christians. A person can choose to follow Jesus, that’s the basic definition of what a Christian is, someone who follows Jesus.
So is being Christian just an individual thing? Well no. Groups can be Christian too. We are a group of people gathered together to follow Jesus – individually we are Christian, but collectively we are Christian too.
We are a Christian Church, gathered to sing Christian hymns and pray Christian prayers, we recite the historic Christian creeds and join in the ancient Christian practice of sharing bread and wine in remembrance of Jesus. We are Christian together.
But does that, can that, should that, translate to an entire country? I don’t think it can, because a country is a much more complex idea.
Now England (or Great Britain, or the United Kingdom, depending on what you think of as our ‘country’) absolutely has Christian values and principles woven through its history and structures, though there are influences from many other religions and schools of thought as well.
Our laws are based in many ways on the morality of the Ten Commandments (though of course that is Jewish rather than Christian if you really want to be picky!). Much of our civic life is shaped around and by the Christian church – Remembrance Sunday for example in a few weeks time.
There are Angican Bishops in the House of Lords. Our Head of State, King Charles the 3rd, is also head of the Church of England – but does that make us a Christian country, or does that make us an English Church?
And then there are the statistics. Fractionally under half of the population put Christian as their religion on the last census – the largest group by a long way – but only about 5% of the population attend Church regularly. Can we be a Christian country if most people don’t go to Church? It can be dangerous to conflate too closely being a “good Englishman” with being a good Christian – there is crossover, but they are not the same.
And what about the nearly 40% who don’t hold to any faith at all? Or the 11% of the population who identify as following other faiths? Are they English? Of course they are, despite what the racist voices in some sections of the media and politics would have you believe! So can England be a “Christian country” if most people aren’t Christians?
It is complicated, of course it is, and to be perfectly honest it’s probably not the right question to be asking at all. But it does raise an important issue, which is that of the tension between our religious duty and our civic duty. Our responsibilities to the state, and our responsibility to God. And that is a tension that people of faith – any faith – have always wrestled with.
We see exactly that tension in today’s Gospel reading.
It comes during a long sequence of stories in Matthew’s Gospel where the religious leaders are trying again and again to catch Jesus out. And here they think they’ve found the question that will stump even him. “Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar or not?”
Taxes, of course, are always contentious, but they are particularly contentious here. When they took over control of Judea in 6AD the Romans imposed a Poll Tax on every person. This was of course fiercely opposed by Jews in and around Jerusalem, and had led to a number of violent uprisings against the Roman occupiers.
Jesus, however, was from Galilee, which was not subject to the Poll Tax. So if he said “yes you should pay” although he didn’t have to himself then the crowds would rapidly and probably violently turn against him. But if he said “you shouldn’t pay” then they could call on the Roman guards and have Jesus arrested for inciting insurrection. Either way it was a win-win for his opponents. Their trap was set.
But Jesus sets a trap of his own. Because he doesn’t answer yes you should pay or no you shouldn’t pay, he simply says “Show me the coin used for the tax.”
One of the religious leaders steps into the trap and hands him a coin. Jesus looks at the coin and says “Whose head, and whose title, is on this coin?” The trap is tightening.
Now what are the first and second commandments? You shall have no other Gods but me, and you shall not make for yourself any graven images. But on this coin, given to Jesus by one of the religious leaders, there was engraved an image of Caesar, along with the inscription Divi Filius, Son of a God.
Now devout Jews of Jesus’s time took the ten commandments very seriously, as you would expect. And so in the Judean province of the Roman Empire they had special dispensation to mint their own coins. Coins which did not have this engraving of Caesar or the inscription ‘Divi Filius‘ on them. And they did this so that they could use the Roman currency without breaking the first and second commandments.
But the coin that the religious leader gives to Jesus is not one of those coins. Because when Jesus asks “Whose head, and whose title, is on this coin?” how does the religious leader reply? “Caesar”. And the trap shuts.
Because in doing this Jesus has revealed their own hipocrisy. He has shown them, and the crowd who are watching, that those religious leaders are just as much in the pocket of the Empire as the hated tax collectors like Matthew – who is the one telling us this story- had been.
They have already chosen sides and they are on the side of power. Money. Oppression. Empire. Jesus knows this, and has skillfuly slipped out of their rhetorical trap and has caught them in a trap of his own.
“Give back to Caesar the things that belong to Caesar”, he concludes, “and give to God the things that belong to God.”
So how does this story help us to hold the tension between being citizens of an earthly country and followers of Jesus?
Well firstly I think it does tell us that we should take our civic responsibilities seriously. We should pay our taxes, not try to dodge them or cheat on them.
We should follow the laws and judgments of those who are in authority, even if in our democratic society we may also work and vote to change those laws.
We should pray for, and show respect to our leaders, as both St Peter and St Paul urge us to do later in the New Testament. We are earthly citizens, and we should do what we can to play a full part in the life of our community and our society.
But we should never forget that the first and only right focus of our worship is the living God. We shouldn’t be sucked into the oh so tempting trap of vowing to thee our country above all earthly things, putting it entirely and wholly at the service of our love.
And we should stand firmly against the attitudes of racism and xenophobia that are so insidious in our society. That judge people as being worth less than us based on the colour of their skin or the place of their birth. There is absolutely nothing Christian in that kind of nationalism.
Our calling is to live as good citizens in a way that gives glory to God.
Because, of course, when we really think through Jesus’s answer – give to Caesar what is Caesar’s, and give to God what is God’s – we find that it is an impossible distinction. Because at the end of the day, what is not God’s?
God who made the heavens and the earth, who made the soil of our land, who made the metals in our coins, who made Caesar himself, surely the answer is to offer everything we have and everything we are in worship to God? From our tithes and taxes to our hobbies and our housework.
We can argue over whether England is a Christian country, but what really matters is how we live as Christian people. Whether we love God with everything we have, and love our neighbour, both local and global, as ourselves. Whether we are willing to give our whole lives to God or, like those religious leaders, we want to hold back, keep some power and wealth for ourselves.
If we do choose to hold back then we know that Jesus sees right through that. But if we can lay all that we are, all that we have, at God’s throne then we will find a sense of purpose, a sense of belonging, a sense of self-worth that no country, no empire, no earthly realm could ever compete with. We may be British Citizens, or citizens of some other realm, but first and foremost we are citizens of the Kingdom of God.
Amen.
Image from https://rpc.ashmus.ox.ac.uk/coins/1/620





